The Driver Who Hit You Was Arrested for DUI. Now What?

Dedicated Personal Injury Lawyer in Santa Clarita, Valencia, Canyon Country, Newhall, Saugus, Stevenson Ranch, Castaic, Val Verde, Antelope Valley, Palmdale, Lancaster, the San Fernando Valley, and the Greater Los Angeles Area

Every year between Thanksgiving and New Year’s, my phone rings with the same kind of call. Someone was driving home on Bouquet Canyon, Soledad Canyon, or the 14 freeway, and a driver who had been drinking crossed the line, causing an accident. Deputies made an arrest at the scene. And the person on the phone says some version of: “He got arrested, so it’s being handled, right?”

Not quite. An arrest starts a criminal case: the People of the State of California versus the at-fault drunk driver. Your injury claim against the drunk driver is a completely separate case, and nobody files it for you.

I spent nearly a decade on the other side, defending insurance companies. Here is what actually happens after a DUI crash, and where injured people leave money on the table without realizing it.

On this page (9 sections)
  1. Two cases, two courtrooms
  2. Common injuries in drunk driving accidents
  3. Why you shouldn’t wait for the criminal case to finish
  4. Restitution is not compensation
  5. Watch the plea deal
  6. Can you get punitive damages?
  7. Who actually pays?
  8. What to do in the week following an accident with a drunk driver
  9. The bottom line

Two Cases, Two Courtrooms

An accident caused by a drunk driver that results in a DUI case generally branches into two separate and different types of cases:

  • A criminal case that is brought by the district attorney’s office
  • A civil case that would be your responsibility
Criminal Case Civil (Injury) Case
Who brings it The L.A. County District Attorney You
Your role Victim and witness Plaintiff
Proof required Beyond a reasonable doubt More likely than not
What is decided Guilt and punishment Who pays you and how much
What you can recover Restitution for out-of-pocket expenses Damages, pain and suffering, and possible punitive damages

The two cases run on separate tracks. A conviction helps your injury case, but you don’t need a conviction to win it. Even if the DUI charge is reduced or dismissed (say, the blood test gets thrown out on a technicality), you can still prove the driver was careless and caused your injuries.

Call The Mason Law Firm, managed by Santa Clarita Personal Injury Attorney Mason Rashtian, today at 661-506-2994 for a FREE consultation. We serve clients throughout Santa Clarita, Valencia, Newhall, Saugus, Canyon Country, Stevenson Ranch, Castaic, Val Verde and all of Los Angeles County.

Common Injuries in Drunk Driving Accidents

Cases involving drunk drivers can result in catastrophic injuries, including:

  • Traumatic brain injuries (TBI). These injuries range anywhere from mild concussions to severe, long-lasting cognitive deficits and impairment.
  • Spinal cord injuries. Depending on the severity of the injury, this can unfortunately result in temporary or permanent paralysis.
  • Crushing injuries. A severe accident can result in a crushing injury. Indeed, I just spoke with the parents of an unfortunate young man who had his leg amputated because his leg was crushed after being hit by a drunk driver.
  • Internal injuries. This includes internal bleeding and organ damage.
  • Bone fractures. These are particularly common in high-speed collisions.
  • Soft tissue injuries, including whiplash, sprains, and strains.
  • Burn injuries, in cases involving fire or explosion.

Why You Shouldn’t Wait for the Criminal Case to Finish

This is the most common mistake I see. People assume they should let the criminal case play out first. That is not a good idea. Here is why:

  • Your deadline keeps running. In California you generally have two years from the crash to file an injury lawsuit. If a government vehicle or employee was involved, you only have six months to file a claim.
  • You cannot wait for your treatment. If you put off treatment while you wait for the criminal case to move forward and wrap up, you create a gap in your treatment. That is bad for your health, because it delays your recovery and healing, and it is bad for your injury claim against the drunk driver.
  • Criminal cases are slow. Between arraignment, continuances, and plea negotiations, a DUI case can take a year or more.
  • Evidence disappears. Bar and restaurant receipts, surveillance video (often recorded over within days or weeks), vehicle data, and witness memories. Law enforcement preserves what it needs to prove the crime, not what you need to prove your damages.
  • The driver may refuse to talk. While criminal charges are pending, the driver can invoke the Fifth Amendment and decline to answer questions in your civil case. A good lawyer plans around that instead of waiting on it.

Restitution Is Not Compensation

As a crime victim, California’s Constitution (Marsy’s Law) gives you the right to be notified about the case, to be heard at sentencing, and to receive restitution.

But restitution only covers “economic losses,” such as medical bills, lost wages, property damage, and similar out-of-pocket costs. A restitution hearing does NOT cover or pay for pain, suffering, emotional distress, or the things you can no longer do. Those damages are available only in a civil case.

Tip: A restitution order is only as good as the driver’s ability to pay it. The driver’s insurance company may not be involved in paying it at all.

Watch the Plea Deal

Most DUI cases end in a plea bargain, and the type of plea matters to your injury case:

  • Guilty plea: can be used against the driver as an admission in your civil case.
  • No contest plea to a charge punishable as a felony (like DUI causing injury, Vehicle Code Section 23153, which can be charged either way): treated the same as a guilty plea and usable as an admission.
  • No contest plea to a misdemeanor-only charge (like a standard DUI or a “wet reckless”): by law, it cannot be used against the driver as an admission in a civil suit arising from the crash.

From the defense side: When I was on the defense side, we paid close attention to what a criminal case was pleaded down to. You have the right to share your views with the prosecutor before a plea is accepted. A misdemeanor plea doesn’t sink your injury case; we still prove it with the evidence. But you should know what’s at stake.

Can You Get Punitive Damages?

In car accident cases, punitive damages are rarely recoverable. Drunk driving cases are the major exception.

So, yes. In 1979, in a case called Taylor v. Superior Court, the California Supreme Court held that punitive damages can be awarded against a drunk driver who acted with conscious disregard for the safety of others.

However, while a civil case can be proven by a “preponderance of the evidence” (more likely than not), a punitive damages claim has to be proven by “clear and convincing evidence,” which falls somewhere between a preponderance of the evidence and “beyond a reasonable doubt.” So the facts become important. To make a claim for punitive damages, we generally need facts such as a very high blood alcohol level, prior DUIs, driving on a suspended license, speeding, or fleeing the scene.

From the defense side: Here’s the part most people don’t know: in California, insurance can’t pay punitive damages. Public policy doesn’t allow a wrongdoer to shift that punishment onto an insurer, so it comes out of the driver’s own pocket. I can tell you a credible punitive damages claim changes how a file gets handled. The driver now has personal exposure, and that creates pressure to resolve the case within the policy limits.

Who Actually Pays?

In most cases, the drunk driver’s liability insurance still covers your injuries. Being intoxicated doesn’t automatically void coverage for the people they hurt. The bigger problem is usually the limits. California’s minimum coverage is only $30,000 per person and $60,000 per accident, and a serious injury blows past that fast.

So we look for every other source:

  • Your own uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage. This is often the most important policy in the case.
  • The vehicle owner, if the driver was in someone else’s car. Owner liability is capped by statute, but it adds coverage.
  • The driver’s employer. If the accident occurred while the at-fault driver was performing his or her duties as an employee, the employer’s insurance can kick in, and it generally carries a higher policy limit.
  • The bar, restaurant, or host. California generally protects anyone who serves alcohol: the law treats drinking, not serving, as the cause. So the bar or establishment that served the alcohol is generally not held liable.

However, there is one exception to this rule. A business that sells alcohol to an obviously intoxicated person under 21 can be held liable. Similarly, an adult who knowingly serves alcohol to someone under 21 in their home could face similar liability.

Tip: That’s why two of my first questions in any DUI case are: How old was the driver, and where were they drinking?

What to Do in the Week Following an Accident With a Drunk Driver

  1. Get the report number. Crashes on city streets in Santa Clarita are handled by the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff’s Station. Crashes on the 5 or the 14 are typically handled by the CHP’s Newhall-area office.
  2. Ask to be notified about the criminal case. The District Attorney’s victim services staff can keep you updated on court dates and sentencing.
  3. Get medical care and keep going. Gaps in treatment are one of the first things an adjuster uses against you.
  4. Don’t give a recorded statement to the drunk driver’s insurance company. You’re not required to, and it won’t help you.
  5. Keep every bill, receipt, and pay stub. You’ll need them for both restitution and your injury claim.
  6. Write down what you saw and heard. The smell of alcohol, open containers, what the driver said, where they said they’d been.
  7. Stay off social media about the crash. Insurers look.
  8. Talk to a personal injury lawyer early, while the evidence still exists.

The Bottom Line

The arrest means the State is holding the driver accountable for breaking the law. Your case is about holding them accountable for what they did to you. It’s a different courtroom, with different rules and different deadlines, and it doesn’t happen unless you start it.

If you or someone in your family was hurt by an impaired driver anywhere in the Santa Clarita Valley, from Valencia and Saugus to Canyon Country, Newhall, and Stevenson Ranch, call The Mason Law Firm. We offer free consultations and work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless we win your case.

📞 Call 661-506-2994 for a free consultation.

Categories

Visit Our Addition Blog Sites: